Skip to main content
  • About Us
  • Careers
  • Contact

Search form

American Institutes for Research

  • Our Work
    • Education
    • Health
    • International
    • Workforce
    • ALL TOPICS >
  • Our Services
    • Research and Evaluation
    • Technical Assistance
  • Our Experts
  • News & Events

You are here

  • Home
16 Sep 2015
Blog Post

We Need More Testing...Of Our Assumptions

Last month the start of the school year was met by a flurry of articles and blog posts about teacher shortages—their scale, nature, and causes. Many commentators blamed today’s student testing and teacher accountability climate for teacher shortages. In a near-viral Education Week blog, Marc Tucker asked why, amid firings of highly regarded teachers due to poor student performance on tests, never mind teacher layoffs during the recession, it should “surprise us that young people would start to avoid teaching careers like the plague?”

In a letter to the editor of The New York Times, American Federation of Teachers President Randi Weingarten wrote, “If you ask teachers why young people are shunning the profession, you’ll get an earful … high-stakes test prep has eclipsed teaching and learning and is sucking the creativity and joy out of classrooms.”

But the truth is we do not know enough about why young people are turning away from teaching or why enrollments at schools of education dropped 30% between 2008-09 and 2012-13.

Even though districts, states, and researchers collect voluminous data on students, there’s virtually none on undergraduate students' attitudes toward the teaching profession and barriers to keeping young people from seriously considering a teaching career. A survey by ACT did find that 5 percent of ACT-takers intend to pursue careers in education, but that percentage was higher five years ago.

As for why the bloom is off the teaching rose, there’s just one research study of young talent and their perspectives on the profession—a 2010 McKinsey & Company market research survey of 1,600 college students, all in the top-third of their classes. Many of these high achievers already planned to go into other fields, and McKinsey wanted to find out which factors about teaching would attract or repel these bright students and how their preferred careers compared to teaching:

  • Salary. Only 17 percent of surveyed college students believed teaching would pay appropriately for their skills and effort compared to 72 percent who believed their preferred careers would. Likewise, 33 percent believed they could support a family on a teacher’s salary, compared to 81 percent in their preferred careers.
  • Work environment. Thirty-three percent of the college students polled saw teaching as offering a well-resourced professional environment, compared to 85 percent in their preferred careers. Similarly, 40 percent believed teaching would provide them with high-quality training and the support needed to improve performance, compared to 80 percent in their preferred careers.
  • Like-minded colleagues. Thirty-nine percent said that teaching attracts the type of people they would want to work with, compared to 77 percent in their preferred careers.

Let’s unpack these survey findings. What type of people do young people want to work with? What does a professional environment mean to them? What type of professional learning or training do they seek in a career? How do current initiatives—such as Teach to Lead, National Board Certification, Teach Plus, America Achieves, and the Teacher Salary Project—appeal to these smart young people contemplating which profession to enter? Are students even aware of these opportunities?

The McKinsey survey did not ask whether bright college students are turned off by the level of student testing or the teacher accountability attached to it.

For that matter, neither do major surveys of those entering the teaching profession.

If over-testing is cutting into student learning time, giving practicing teachers extra cause for worry, and deterring new talent from considering teaching as a career, then research studies should expand on the McKinsey survey to capture the full array of considerations at play when young people decide whether to teach. And education leaders at all levels should complement formal large-scale research with local data collection on their own teacher pipeline.

Earlier this month, Secretary Duncan approved the first round of State Equity Plans. In them, states laid out their strategies for ensuring that students from poor and minority backgrounds would not be shortchanged in their access to effective teachers. A review of the 50 draft state equity plans reveals that all states cited the need to recruit a greater pool of talent to the pipeline but that nary a one has a plan for collecting data on students’ preferences and priorities on the threshold of their careers in—or outside of—teaching.

Rather than assume we know what could make a difference, let’s find out.

Ellen Sherratt is a senior researcher at AIR specializing in teacher compensation, strategic recruitment and retention, and teacher voice. She is the co-deputy director of the Center on Great Teachers and Leaders and President of the Board of the Teacher Salary Project.

Related Work

10 Sep 2019
Spotlight

Teacher-shortage-ONLY-FOR-EPC-101210008_245x165.jpg

Young teachers

Teacher Shortages: Trends, Projections, and What Experts Say

Teacher shortages are widely reported across the United States. But is there more to the story? Research sheds light on the widely-debated questions of shortages, their causes, severity, and ways to respond.
Topic: 
Education, Teacher Preparation and Performance
30 Jun 2016
Brief

teacher-shortage-brief-June-2016.jpg

Teacher shortage report cover

Creating Coherence in the Teacher Shortage Debate: What Policymakers Should Know and Do

Recent media attention has raised significant concerns about our public school system’s capability to staff all classrooms; yet remarkably little research details the nature of teacher shortages. This brief provides a roadmap for policy leaders to hold better informed dialogues on the nature of teacher shortages, and target interventions to rectify teacher shortages where they exist.
Topic: 
Education, Teacher Preparation and Performance

Further Reading

  • The Leaky Pipeline: Why Don't New Teachers Teach?
  • Teacher Leaders: Many Titles, Big Impacts
  • Research vs. Conventional Wisdom I: Teacher Attrition
  • How to Truly Appreciate Teachers: A Q&A With Gretchen Weber, AIR Managing Director
  • Teacher Shortages: Trends, Projections, and What Experts Say
Share

Topic

Education
Teacher Preparation and Performance

RESEARCH. EVALUATION. APPLICATION. IMPACT.

About Us

About AIR
Board of Directors
Leadership
Experts
Clients
Contracting with AIR
Contact Us

Our Work

Education
Health
International
Workforce

Client Services

Research and Evaluation
Technical Assistance

News & Events

Careers at AIR


Search form


 

Connecting

FacebookTwitterLinkedinYouTubeInstagram

American Institutes for Research

1400 Crystal Drive, 10th Floor
Arlington, VA 22202-3289
Call: (202) 403-5000
Fax: (202) 403-5000

Copyright © 2021 American Institutes for Research®.  All rights reserved.

  • Privacy Policy
  • Sitemap