Skip to main content
  • About Us
  • Careers
  • Contact

Search form

American Institutes for Research

  • Our Work
    • Education
    • Health
    • International
    • Workforce
    • ALL TOPICS >
  • Our Services
    • Research and Evaluation
    • Technical Assistance
  • Our Experts
  • News & Events

You are here

  • Home
14 Oct 2016
Blog Post

Can More Data Help Improve Teacher Preparation?

The U.S. Department of Education’s new regulations for teacher preparation programs ask states and organizations that prepare teachers to provide much more data about graduates’ competence, their persistence in the teacher workforce, and their impact on student learning. In the works since 2012, these new regulations differ from what states must report under the current regulations in Title II of the Higher Education Act.

The big shift is that starting in the next school year, states must collect outcome data from teacher preparation programs that goes beyond the current data—such as the number of teacher candidates; their race, ethnicity, and gender; and the percentage who pass state certification exams. U.S. Department of Education Secretary John King called the information collected until now “surface level” data and said that the information required under the new regulations would give a much deeper look at how well teacher preparation programs prepare effective teachers.

For the most part, the new data requirements focus on such outcome-driven questions as:

  • Are employers satisfied with their new teachers’ abilities?
  • Do new teachers stay in the profession?
  • Can new teachers raise student achievement?
  • Do new teachers themselves believe they were well-prepared to teach?

No doubt answers to these questions can provide teacher educators, school districts, and principals with more data about teacher preparation programs and their graduates already in the field.  But earlier indicators could signal problems long before candidates graduate.

Research shows that an effective teacher can raise student achievement above the norm. Plus, brand-new teachers often end up teaching students in the most disadvantaged schools and communities. So their ability to teach well on day one is essential to the students who most need excellent teaching.

And states are very aware of that need. Forty-five states’ current equity plans cite improving educator preparation and certification as a strategy for ensuring equitable access to excellent educators. Analysis of the new data should inform and incite a productive policy dialogue.

As for what we can expect under the new regulations, states will now have to collect data on teacher-preparation programs, use it to evaluate each program’s effectiveness, and rate each program. Programs rated as less than effective for two out of three years will no longer be able to offer federal Teacher Education Assistance for College and Higher Education (TEACH) grants, which award up to $4,000 per year to teacher candidates preparing to work in high-needs schools and subjects. Withdrawal of TEACH grants from less than effective programs will take effect in the 2021-22 school year.

Analysis of the new data can point to weak teacher programs—after the fact. What’s missing is a measure of weakness before a program falters, before its candidates graduate and start teaching. To ensure that all students have access to effective teachers, teacher educators should assess their candidates long before they are placed in classrooms. That would let teacher educators get individual candidates back on track—or adjust their programs to better prepare candidates. 

Some programs are trying a “rounds” model, similar to those used in medical training. Teacher candidates visit multiple classrooms to watch different teachers use specific teaching practices. Others give candidates more carefully structured feedback on their student teaching.

On the technology front, a new simulator lets candidates practice in a virtual, no-stakes environment—like rookie pilots do when learning to fly airplanes. Would-be teachers master such instructional moves as asking open-ended questions or responding to student misunderstanding, long before they try them out with children.

It may ask a lot of federal policy to inspire deep transformations that could improve what teacher educators do to prepare teacher candidates to become skilled and ready to support student learning. But perhaps as this new, wider data collection becomes routine, as the ratings are published, and as aspiring teachers choose to attend the best-rated programs, the field may be inspired to design and test new ways to prepare teachers and assess their effectiveness before they finish their program, before they enter the field, and before their teacher preparation program is held accountable for their performance.

 Jenny DeMonte specializes in teacher preparation and licensure. She has worked on research and policy issues related to teacher quality and school improvement for more than two decades—first as a journalist and now as an AIR researcher.

Related Work

8 Jun 2015
Blog Post

DeMonte Jenny_4.jpg

Jenny DeMonte

Lighting the Fuse on Teacher Preparation 2.0

One of the most enduring myths about teaching is that it’s easy. In this blog post, Jenny DeMonte, a senior technical assistance consultant at AIR, debunks that myth and suggests coaching in essential practices, providing immediate feedback, and conveying common knowledge and competences as critical elements of successful teacher preparation programs.
Topic: 
Education, Teacher Preparation and Performance
12 Nov 2015
Blog Post

DeMonte Jenny_4.jpg

Jenny DeMonte

Make Sure New Teachers Are Ready Before They Graduate

The federal regulations on teacher preparation, scheduled to be released next month, ask for a lot of new data about how well graduates perform in schools. But for students in those schools that might be too late. What's missing is a measure that can signal weakness or problems before candidates graduate and start teaching. Jenny DeMonte discusses how some states are addressing this problem.
Topic: 
Education, Teacher Preparation and Performance
4 Feb 2016
Blog Post

DeMonte Jenny_4.jpg

Jenny DeMonte

The Leaky Pipeline: Why Don't New Teachers Teach?

Between a quarter and a half of those who complete a teacher preparation program don’t end up teaching after graduation. In our latest blog post, AIR’s Jenny DeMonte encourages policymakers to start tracking this data to help address teacher shortages and improve the teacher pipeline.
Topic: 
Education, Teacher Preparation and Performance
29 Feb 2016
Video

lss_jenny_demonte-01_245x165.png

Jenny DeMonte

Long Story Short: Why is Teacher Preparation Critical for the Next Decade?

In the next decade, almost half of the teaching workforce will be comprised of new teachers. In this video interview, AIR's Jenny DeMonte talks about teacher preparation and the ways we can enhance programs to improve teacher quality.
Topic: 
Education, Teacher Preparation and Performance
29 May 2015
Policy Brief

A Million New Teachers Are Coming: Will They Be Ready to Teach?

Research shows that the most powerful, in-school influence on learning is the quality of instruction that teachers bring to their students. In the next decade, more than 1.5 million new teachers will be hired for our schools; unfortunately, teacher preparation programs may not be up to the task of delivering the teacher workforce we need. This brief describes elements of an effective start-to-finish look at teacher preparation.
Topic: 
Education, Teacher Preparation and Performance
10 Sep 2019
Spotlight

Teacher-shortage-ONLY-FOR-EPC-101210008_245x165.jpg

Young teachers

Teacher Shortages: Trends, Projections, and What Experts Say

Teacher shortages are widely reported across the United States. But is there more to the story? Research sheds light on the widely-debated questions of shortages, their causes, severity, and ways to respond.
Topic: 
Education, Teacher Preparation and Performance

Further Reading

  • Make Sure New Teachers Are Ready Before They Graduate
  • The Leaky Pipeline: Why Don't New Teachers Teach?
  • A Million New Teachers Are Coming: Will They Be Ready to Teach?
  • Lighting the Fuse on Teacher Preparation 2.0
  • Better Data May Equal Better Prepared Teachers
Share

Topic

Education
Teacher Preparation and Performance

RESEARCH. EVALUATION. APPLICATION. IMPACT.

About Us

About AIR
Board of Directors
Leadership
Experts
Clients
Contracting with AIR
Contact Us

Our Work

Education
Health
International
Workforce

Client Services

Research and Evaluation
Technical Assistance

News & Events

Careers at AIR


Search form


 

Connecting

FacebookTwitterLinkedinYouTubeInstagram

American Institutes for Research

1400 Crystal Drive, 10th Floor
Arlington, VA 22202-3289
Call: (202) 403-5000
Fax: (202) 403-5000

Copyright © 2021 American Institutes for Research®.  All rights reserved.

  • Privacy Policy
  • Sitemap